Discovery agents stop asking only true or false: swapping a hypothesis for rival explanations resolves 67% more questions at the same budget
Scientific discovery agents usually test one hypothesis at a time, so when evidence rejects it the agent learns that one explanation is unlikely but not which alternative the evidence supports. Contrastive Discovery replaces each discovery step with a set of mutually exclusive, collectively exhaustive competing explanations for the same question, and scores an experiment by how far its evidence redistributes belief across that set. Across six datasets spanning materials, astronomy, mortgage discrimination, online discourse, software engineering practice and social behavior, guiding search with contrast sets resolved 67% more questions than pointwise surprisal under the same experiment budget, and 38 blinded experts chose the same explanation on 78% of resolved questions.