Rotation invariants can blur highly symmetric molecules: an extended HIP-HOP basis gives the lowest error among HIP-HOP variants on methane and still runs faster at inference
Rotation-invariant representations can map geometrically distinct atomic environments onto the same descriptor in highly symmetric settings, limiting the accuracy of machine-learned interatomic potentials. A lightweight benchmark built around configurations with multiple-fold symmetry exposes degeneracies shared by invariant and equivariant architectures, and guides an extension of the invariant HIP-HOP basis to higher angular order. On a randomly displaced methane dataset of more than seven million configurations, the extended basis gives the lowest error among HIP-HOP variants and, at about 36K parameters, nearly matches EquiformerV3 while running faster at inference; both still fail on the (3/4) ring configuration.