SOFA's 1996 expert thresholds give way to outcome-fitted cutpoints, lifting ICU mortality AUROC from 0.751 to 0.811
The SOFA score used in intensive care has kept the thresholds and 0-to-4 point bands set by expert consensus in 1996, never re-estimated from outcome data. In 14,848 adult first ICU admissions from the multicenter eICU database, a study re-learned each organ component's cutpoints and weights while keeping an additive, integer, bedside-computable form, using supervised discretization plus weight optimization under monotonicity and integrality constraints. In 10-fold nested cross-validation grouped by hospital, the recalibrated score reached an ICU mortality AUROC of 0.811 versus 0.751 for a prespecified SOFA-derived reference score, a paired difference of 0.059.