Skip to main content
Back to timeline
arXivSource publication:

Amplituhedron tilings need not follow the magic number: a degree-two cell yields a tiling one tile short

Synopsis

The amplituhedron is the geometric object behind super Yang-Mills amplitudes; known tilings used only degree-one cells, and even-dimensional cases were conjectured to need a "magic number" of tiles. A degree-two injective cell is constructed, and three bistellar flips turn a known BCFW tiling into one with one tile fewer than the magic number. The authors propose a new lower-bound conjecture on tile counts and note that the counterexamples were first found by ChatGPT.

AI-generated editorial illustration: Two examples in amplituhedron tilings

Interpretation

An amplituhedron admits a tiling with one fewer cell than the magic number conjecture prescribes, refuting the strong form of that conjecture. Previously known amplituhedron tilings used only degree-one cells, while the magic number conjecture held that even-dimensional cases have a tiling with exactly that many tiles. In the physically important four-dimensional case, three bistellar flips applied to a known BCFW tiling give a tiling with one tile fewer than the magic number.

The construction hinges on a degree-two injective cell, used in the third bistellar flip. A bistellar flip is a local replacement: a set of adjacent cells is swapped for another set covering the same region. The first two flips each swap five tiles for five, the third swaps seven for six, and the remaining cells involved have degree one.

Such degree-two injective cells extend to arbitrarily high degree. A single example only shows the four-dimensional case, while iterating a combinatorial construction pushes the degree higher. Repeatedly applying the construction in the four-dimensional case gives injective cells of unbounded degree; relaxing the assumption allows arbitrary degree.

Perspective

The scope is the combinatorial geometry of amplituhedron tilings; the concrete counterexample targets the physically important four-dimensional case, and higher dimensions are mentioned only as where similar phenomena were first found. The intended reader is a researcher familiar with the positive Grassmannian and its cell decomposition.

The new conjecture is only consistent with the available evidence and remains unproven; the counterexamples were first found by ChatGPT, and the authors take full responsibility for the correctness of all statements.