OpenAI Codex redoes CMS open data: J/psi cross sections in 39 bins match published values with mean ratio 1.000
Synopsis
Under stage-by-stage review by physicists, OpenAI's Codex coding agent carried out a J/psi analysis of CMS open data, covering dimuon event selection, two-dimensional mass and decay-length fits, Geant4 full-detector simulation and systematic uncertainty evaluation. Across 39 kinematic bins of the 2010 proton-proton remeasurement, the ratio to published CMS cross sections has a mean of 1.000 and an RMS spread of 0.215; across six peripheral PbPb intervals from 2011 the mean ratio is 1.158 with an RMS of 0.225, and the reanalysis uncertainty intervals overlap the published values in all six.
Interpretation
A large-language-model coding agent supervised by human physicists can carry a CMS open-data analysis from event selection through cross-section extraction without ready-made signal simulations or trigger efficiencies. Earlier open-data reanalyses required people to configure legacy software, detector simulation and systematic uncertainties, and these two data releases provide neither dedicated reconstructed charmonium simulations nor precomputed trigger efficiencies. In the 2010 proton-proton remeasurement, the ratios of remeasured to published cross sections across 39 kinematic bins have a mean of 1.000, an RMS of 0.215 and a median of 1.000, with 36 bins inside one standard deviation.
The workflow splits the analysis into five stages, learning, event selection, information extraction, Monte Carlo correction and systematic uncertainty evaluation, and each stage ends at a checkpoint where a physicist inspects numbers and diagnostic plots before work continues. The agent is not confined to the information in its instruction; when details are missing it searches public sources such as the Particle Data Group and records the references for human verification. On the 2011 peripheral PbPb data, the agent first used the official reprocessing configuration to establish that the public sample retains only 50-100% centrality, then produced results consistent with published values in six matched intervals.
The agent configured and ran full-detector simulations itself, generating 238,180 unpolarized prompt J/psi decays with Pythia6 interfaced to Geant4 for acceptance and efficiency corrections. No ready simulation existed on the PbPb side, so the agent generated quenched minimum-bias background with HYDJET and embedded Pythia6 signal into it before Geant4 simulation, trigger emulation and track reconstruction. Across the six PbPb intervals the reanalysis ratios have a mean of 1.158, an RMS of 0.225 and a median of 1.158, and the reanalysis uncertainty intervals overlap the published CMS uncertainty bands in all six.
Perspective
The demonstrated scope is the CMS 2010 7 TeV proton-proton dimuon data and the 2011 2.76 TeV peripheral PbPb dimuon data, both from the CERN Open Data Portal, with physicist review at every stage. On the proton-proton side only a single unprescaled Tight dimuon trigger is used, so the effective integrated luminosity is lower than that of the published analysis.
The proton-proton reanalysis lacks data-driven trigger scale factors, pileup reweighting and bottom-quark feed-down corrections, and these sources are marked as unevaluated. On the PbPb side external single-muon efficiency calibrations are transferred to the embedded simulation, while heavy-ion tracking-efficiency and occupancy-closure corrections have not been established, so the six-interval comparison is framed as a conditional consistency check.
